|
|
|
|
Sustainability and Environmental Awareness:
Keeping Farmers on Their Farms in Poland
By John Babb
Jadwiga Lopata sits on the stoop of her house, nestled in the foothills
of the Biskidy mountains, gazing at Babia Gora, the highest peak. It is a
view she took for granted as a child growing up in the area, and it was the
thought of being unable to see the mountains again that persuaded Lopata to
reconsider her life style and return to the village where she was raised.
Jadwiga Lopata
"I was working as a computer programmer and I was losing my sight,"
Lopata said. "The doctor said I would need an operation." She suspected
that staring at a computer screen was responsible, so she quit. It was not
long after that, as she puts it, that she had a vision of how organic
farming and tourism could preserve a way of life she remembered as a child.
Lopata was not a farmer, but her near loss of sight made her more aware
of her environment and life style and how it is linked to personal health.
She was in search of a more holistic approach but at the same time was
mindful that she had a 10-year-old son to support. The emerging
nature-tourism market appealed to her needs at the time: A way to make
money from a respect for nature.
The traditional family farm in Poland is no longer economically viable.
Of the nearly two million farms, 68 percent are family operations on 5 to
7.5 hectares. Farming was one of the few sectors that were not nationalized
under Communism, but as Poland makes the transition to a free market, the
structural problems of the family farms have become all too apparent.
"None of us can make a living off agriculture; we all have second
jobs," said a strawberry farmer, Stanislaw Nicieja.
The Financial and Commercial Pressures
Among the many problems, the Government is reducing subsidies, freer
trade with the European Union is driving down food prices and the farmers
cannot match the economies of scale of the large agrobusiness farms in
Western Europe.
The pressure for Polish farmers to mimic western strategies are
enormous. The Government is trying to force consolidation. Larger farms are
offering quick cash for land and chemical companies are offering fertilizer
at reduced cost or no cost to entice farmers to use western
agricultural practices.
Polish farm
For Lopata, this is not the solution. She fears it will lead to the
destruction of rural communities, the degradation of the land and the
contamination of the water. She has two goals: To protect the environment
and to keep people on the family farm by making it profitable. What she has
done is to find a method to extract the inherent value of the Polish farm.
"This is our big treasure, the Polish countryside, this is what we can
offer to our visitors, this really picturesque landscape still not so
destroyed, nature not so poisoned, and good farmers who can in a very short
time turn to organic production."
The Attraction of the Olden Days
Horses pulling plows, hayrides, straw mattresses, homemade cheese and
sausages: Compared to western norms, the Polish farm is caught in a time
warp circa 1920. There are no combines and few tractors. Nearly everything
used by the farm is produced on the farm. It is like a Disneyland
attraction, a tableau in a museum of civilization.
Hay ride on the farm
Lopata was sure that if she could educate the farmers to operate tourist
attractions, people would pay money to experience the life style. But it is
only a bankable proposition if she can preserve the family farm.
The second part of her plan was to offset plummeting produce prices by
capitalizing on the increasing demand for organic foods, which sell at a
premium. So 10 years ago Lopata began to sell her idea of nature-tourism.
No such industry existed in Poland, so Lopata went off to the
Netherlands to study the industry. It was during her time in the
Netherlands that she co-founded the European Center for Ecological
Agriculture and Tourism (ECEAT), which now has 60 members in 10 countries
across Europe and North America. The center acts as a hub for farms in each
country, handling the promotion of organic farms and providing training and
support.
Applying Lessons Learned in the Netherlands
Lopata returned to Poland in 1993 to create an eco-tourism industry.
People learn from example, so she knew she needed to start with one farm
and get it working to convince others. Her first step was to rent a room on
a farm near Zelana Gora, in southwestern Poland. She was attracted to the
farm house because of its potential to be adapted for tourists. All that
needed to be done was to clear out a few rooms. The farm house had three
extra rooms that she convinced the owners to clean out and paint. They
found an old bed in the attic that Grandmother used to sleep in and the
stage was set.
Since she was rooming there, she could help train the farmers to
accommodate guests. Lopata also publicized the farm through her contacts in
the Netherlands. When tourists started to come, she invited neighboring
farmers by to see what could be accomplished without a big investment.
"They couldn't imagine that someone would come to a facility like they
had, which is not true, because there are quite a large number of people
who accept things like common toilets. I keep telling farmers: That's how
we started."
Potato harvest on a family farm in Stryszow, Poland
From those humble beginnings Lopata has formalized the process for
joining ECEAT. On average it takes a Polish farm two years to make the
switch to organic production, which means weaning the soil off artificial
fertilizer and halting the use of herbicides and pesticides. The only
criterion for joining is agricultural experience, as opposed to being
interested only in running a bed-and-breakfast pension in the country. The
recruitment of farmers is usually done by example.
"We are getting requests from all over Poland from different farmers
who want to join," Lopata said. "I already have a collection of
different addresses for the 2000 season."
The Selection Process
Lopata or her son and partner, Chris, visits applicants and assesses the
facilities, giving advice on any changes needed to be made, stressing
minimal investment. The farmers must then start down the road to organic
production. To this end Lopata relies on a sister organization, Ecoland,
which administers an internationally recognized certification program for
organic produce. Ecoland provides the training and monitors the farms for a
membership fee equivalent to $20 a year, and a certification fee based on
the size of the farm. A 1- to 5-hectare farm will cost $37.50 to $45.
When a farm meets the requirements for at least half its products, the
owners are ready to begin to train with ECEAT. Lopata does this by sending
new farmers to an established farm. By being a guest at a farm, they get a
first-hand understanding of what it takes to be a good host. The host
farmer also teaches business skills, tourism, health and the philosophy
behind sustainablity. Lopata believes this is the power of her program,
that she persuades farmers by showing, not telling. When a farmer goes to
a farm that is working, there is no arguing that it can't be done.
Tourists' dollars are, of course, of prime interest, and each year more
visitors come to ECEAT farms. In 1993, there were 14 farms that attracted
400 visitors; last year there were 60 farms attracting more than 3,000. A
brochure, also published and mounted on the Internet in Polish, English, Dutch
and German, markets the farms.
Taxi please! Traditional rural transportation in the Zawoja community.
Most of the visitors are like Kees Veenstra, from the Netherlands.
Veenstra and his wife have visited the same farm three times. "We just
don't have anything like this in the Netherlands," said Veenstra. They
spend their time either helping with the farm chores, biking or hiking
through the nearby forest or visiting World War II sites in and around
Krakow. For this they pay between $5 and $10 a night and an extra $5 to
$10 for hot meals, modest sums but to some farmers an income too tempting
to resist.
Keeping Farmers Focused on Their Land
One ironic problem is that some farmers are turning away from
agriculture toward the easier money from tourism, which happened to one of
the first farms Lopata had converted. "It really took me a lot of effort
to convince them and promote them, and they escaped," Lopata said. She
regards running simply a bed-and-breakfast in the country as short-sighted
because it does not help preserve the land and is economically riskier.
Lopata estimates that 2 to 3 percent of the farmers who go through Ecoland
and ECEAT training defect.
Lopata cited some of the disadvantages to focusing exclusively on
tourism and trying to link up farms through major travel agencies. The
agencies, for example, insist on standard furniture in each room, or
certain washroom facilities. But most farmers do not have any extra money
for such investments so they must borrow, and loan rates in Poland are near
20 percent. Though a farmer may be able to charge more for a "fancier"
room, the money goes towards interest payments.
Lopata refers back to the first farm she converted, where the only
investment was a bit of paint. With her model, if farming fails, you can
rely on tourist income, and vice versa. Even if both fail, you do not have
the added burden of paying off a loan.
With the ECEAT model, the money remains on the farm, though the
association gets 10 percent of the tourist income to give the program a
measure of financial independence. The money goes toward producing and
mailing a monthly newsletter and promoting the farms. The rest of the
funding is cobbled together through grants.
The Scramble for Funds
In the early stages it was difficult to get backing. "Everyone was
looking to the other sources," Lopata said. "The Dutch Embassy asked,
`What did you get from other sources?' We had only promises. I just told
[the Dutch contact], `You know, someone has to start to give, otherwise
everyone keeps asking, "Did you get from other sources?"' So she said O.K."
The Dutch will give 10,000 guilders this year. ECEAT will also get
$8,000 from the American Embassy and $25,000 from the Rockefeller Brothers
Fund. The center has yet to receive any money from the Polish Government,
although it has contributed indirectly by covering travel costs and making
space available at the local community office.
Apart from tourists, ECEAT farms are also attracting professional tour
agencies and associations that want to contract some of her farms.
Companies like SNP Natuurreizen, the biggest tourist organization in the
Netherlands; Dobry Den, another Dutch agency, and Green Travel Network of
the United States, are all following her lead. For Lopata, this is a
measure of her success, and she sees it as an opportunity for her more
advanced farms, where she can train and promote new farmers.
The number of tourists exposed to the benefits of organic agriculture
and the family-farm lifestyle grows with the number of farms. They are the
best promotion for the program, Lopata said. "Tourism is a very good tool
to spread the idea of organic agriculture and it's working, really working
in practice because people become convinced when they see the production,
the atmosphere on the farms. They will speak about it to their friends, and
so the circle gets bigger and bigger."
Lopata's largest organic farm is 150 hectares but she expects larger
farms to get interested in organic production. "There are already big
organic farms in Poland; one is even 1000 hectares. The way to convince
farmers, though, is that they have to know about the possibility of selling
organic food in Poland and E.U. countries. Permanent support from the
Government would also be very important."
Now that Lopata's eco-tourism plan is beginning to take off, she has
embarked on a more ambitious project: the eco-village. A year and a half
ago she bought a small farm near Stryszow, her home, to create a village
that will apply ecological solutions in education, tourism, energy use and
waste treatment and disposal. The first step was to convince local farmers
that organic farming can be profitable and that small-scale tourism is a
viable way to supplement farm income. She first had to convince the
community of her vision. "You have to make them feel that the ideas are
coming from them."
A Crucial Battle Over a Hotel
This is how she was able to prevent Stryszow from following what she
considered a destructive path. The local government was planning to build a
resort on the shore of a nearby lake. "I inspired the other farmers and
told them, when you have a hotel, there will be no income for you. The
money will go to the investors in this hotel and only a few people will be
employed," Lopata said. During this battle Lopata managed to get the town
to incorporate ecology as a tenet of the community. She repeated the
process she used to get the eco-farm program running: leading by example.
Lopata also offers training programs on ecological agriculture,
eco-tourism and ecological life styles that emphasize the importance of
protecting local cultures and economies. To help spread her ideas, she
prints a local newspaper, and in the fall, she hopes to institute courses
for children on ecology-related subjects. In the pipeline are plans to
organize excursions to projects in the Netherlands and the United States
where wind energy and solar energy are being harnessed successfully.
The 20 farmers of Stryszow who will be receiving guests for the first
time this year, and who will become the nucleus of this larger project, are
anxious to reap financial benefits from the program. If they happen to help
the environment, all the better.
"Before Lopata came, we didn't see anything for the future but the
forest expanding to reclaim the land," said Nicieja, the strawberry
farmer. But there are 300 farms in the community, and Lopata hopes that
when they see the successes of farmers like Nicieja this year, next year
they will beat a path to her door.
|
|