2) Alianza Para La Depresion
Submitted: Wednesday, January 5, 2005, 4:51
3) Strategy Summary:
Include our self-help groups in the official treatment for
depression because there are many loose ends in the actual
system. A world authority in depression says treatment is
three dimensional: medication, psychotherapy and self-help
groups. There are advantages for all the elements involved:
the Social Security, the industry, the private sector and
the professionals. We are all interested in the health of
the patient. He is the protagonist, the tax payer, the
consumer and the voter.
We have been working with self-help groups for 10 years
with 7000 people and their families and friends and we have
proved that it works. Now we want the Health Authorities to
take notice of this fact and realize that it improves
health care for the patient
4) How the Strategy Works:
First step: The strategy is to sit all the parties
interested around a table to discuss the advantages or
disadvantages of the idea. Here are de guests:
- The Pharmaceutical Industry, represented by their
association Farmaindustria (in Spain).
- The Medical Association, in Spain called Colegio
de Medicos for psychiatrists and general practitioners.
- Someone representing the Health Authorities and
Social Security. In Spain de Social Security covers most
of the expenses in the treatment of depression. Medicines
are partly paid by the patient except for people in
retirement.
- The Patient's Advocate. In Madrid she is
Margarita Retuerto, good friend of Alianza para la
Depresion and very active.
- Someone representing the Clinical Psychologists or
well known professionals.
- And someone representing the non-profit Patient s
Association.
When we heard of the Ashoka contest we were already
involved in preparing this summit; in fact, we have a
couple of Foundations interested in the matter.
Second step: The media are in the waiting list, ready to
start when we have news for them which will be soon,
before, during and after the summit. We have a call from
the main TV channel in Madrid to call them as soon as we
have organized the meeting.
Third Step: Here is a list of the advantages for each
party:
a) Pharmaceutical Industry. There are many advantages
in having direct access to the Patient s Association. All
ethical and prestigious pharmaceutical companies are
interested to know that their products are properly used
and to receive feedback from the patients.
We are perfectly aware that they cannot promote their
prescription products directly with the patients. It has
to be done through the practitioners, but there are many
other matters of great interest to the manufacturer of a
product to be in touch with the consumer, in this case the
patient. To mention just one case, a pharmaceutical
company (Eisai Co.) in Japan saw this opportunity and has
jumped from rank 6 to rank 2 in a few years.
To give an example, we know of patients that have dropped
using a medicine because they had problems with the package
of the product.
Also, through our many years of experience we have noted
that many patients have the idea that the manufacturers are
a bunch of people interested only in making money. We
explain in our groups that pharmaceutical companies are
mainly interested in the health of the patients and for
this purpose they have to make money which is used in great
part in research to find more and better products. We also
do research work for the pharmaceutical industry having
questionnaires answered by the patients.
The Japanese company launched a new product as a result of
field work with non-profit partient s associations.
With the only restriction of promoting their prescription
drugs there are no other reasons why pharmaceutical
companies can not work with patient s associations.
b) The medical associations. There is practically a
unanimous opinion among physicians of the convenience of
working with the patient s associations. We have a
psychiatrist that has been cooperating with us for four
years, and our president is a professor of psychiatry and a
well known professional writer of several best sellers on
depression. Throughout these 10 years we have met many
physicians and they all agree on the convenience and the
need for the work performed by the self-help groups. We
know of only one case of a doctor that was not convinced
and it was because he was not well acquainted with the work
done by the self-help groups.
If the industry agrees and the ones that are supposed to
know more about the case, which are the physicians, we do
not see many obstacles or objections in the road to make
self-help groups part of the treatment, but there is one
important step to take which is to convince the Health
Authorities. In Spain, with such a wide coverage by
Social Security, this entity represents the largest budget
for the government and they do not see with good eyes
spending additional funds in the caring of these patients.
That is the main reason why we have received very little
help from the administration. As a matter of fact, we have
only received a meager 1,500 euros from the regional
government in these past 10 years. But every problem
contains an opportunity or a solution and we have many
arguments to solve this obstacle.
It is not a donation or an expense; it is an investment.
There is an interesting study done by Cole, Tucker and
Freeman, published in the American Journal of Health
Promotion, in which the authors state that one dollar
invested in associations like ours, four dollars are saved
in health expenditures.
Our idea can be replicated by other organizations. We
belong to a network called GAMIAN (Global Alliance of
Mental Illness Advocary Networks) that includes 57
countries.
5) Key Strategy Elements:
i. Mobilizing Citizen Support:
Citizen support is essential and the political party now in
power has the possibility of gaining three million votes
(number of depressives now in Spain) and they are experts
in mobilizing this support. This is after all and
important part of their work.
Our Founder and Vice President was recently in an
International Meeting of Chronic Illness Patient
Associations and in the questions and answers period he
proposed that our work should be considered by authorities
as part of the treatment for depression and his statement
was received by the audience with applause which proves
that our idea is widely accepted by the Patient
Associations.
ii. Generating Financial and Nonfinancial Resources:
The pharmaceutical industry has already shown great
interest in the self-help associations. The fact that
medical expenditures are reduced does not affect them. The
savings are mostly in visits to the doctors, less
admissions in hospitals, less sick leaves, etc. For the
pharmaceutical industry the great potential is with the
patients that do not follow any treatment at all and
represents a large percentage of people suffering from
depression and these people prefer going to self-help
groups than to the doctor because they do not want people
to think they are crazy. We advise them to go to the
general practitioner first.
iii. Establishing Relationships with Strategic Partnerships:
What makes this idea attractive is that it does not require
a big investment because it has to be done gradually over
the years because there are very few self-help groups. In
Spain it requires 16 associations like ours to cover the
country. At least, one for every Community and that
requires time. At least 6 or 8 years, but this is also an
advantage because like that we are capable of testing the
advantages of these groups and training the moderators to
handle the patients and their families. Alianza para la
Depresion can be very useful in this regard on account of
the number of patients already treated and the experience
to train people.
iv. Engaging and Managing Volunteers:
Most of our staff are volunteers and we have 10 years of
experience in engaging and managing volunteers, even
doctors and psychologists.
v. Developing Information and Spreading the Message:
The main types of spreading the message is through press
releases, interviews, TV news and P.R. work. As said
before, the media has fully cooperated in the past and will
do it more so in the future because the idea is really news
for them and that is what they live on. We already have
calls from the media asking us to call them when we are
ready to start.
6) Increasing Self-sufficiency and Social Impact:
It is obvious that our organization will become self- sufficient and the social impact it will produce. We will
be paid by the Social Security System, and if this fails,
by the Health Insurance Companies, backed by the Industry
and Corporate Foundations, what is known as social
marketing.
As we are talking of 3 million people and their families,
the impact will be very strong. We calculate the cost per
patient 80 euros per month. The length of the treatment is
an average of 3 months. 80% of patients recover. The
initial investment is about 56,000 euros for the first
year. It has to be done gradually starting in Madrid and
proceeding step by step to the other 16 regions of the
country. If by being only in Madrid we have had a big
social impact (7000 patients and thousands of calls from
all over) imagine being in the 16 regions of Spain, and it
can spread to all countries through organizations like
Gamian.
8) Organization Mission and Vision:
Mission: To help 360 million depressives and their families
in the world by strengthening patient s associations
innovative and original approach that will generate funds
and training to those associations.
Vision: To help in an effective way depressive patients
around the world.
Organization Size:
We have now 6 volunteers and one part-time employee. In
three years we will have 4 part-time employees, 2 full-time
and 12 volunteers approximately
Looking Forward to the Next Three Years:
In three years we expect 3 more associations like ours in
Spain which will triple the capacity of our present
association.
Jaime Smith Semprun, Founder and Vice President of Alianza para la Depresi
General Margallo, 27, 1D - 28020 Madrid
Spain
Telephone: 34 91 5703003
Fax: 34 91 5702476
Email: smith@alianzadepresion.com
Web site: alianzadepresion.com