|
|
|
Herbal Remedies For
Social Wellbeing
By Jennifer Gampell
Rosana Tositrakul, secretary general of the Thai Holistic Health
Foundation, sits with three fellow members of her non-governmental
organization on one side of a practically empty conference room at
the Thai Ministry of Public Health. Dr. Narong Chayakul, the newly
appointed secretary general of the Food and Drug Administration of
Thailand, sits at the head of the table, flanked by a handful of F.D.A.
officials.
For the past 15 minutes, the bureaucrats have been
intoning the official position on a draft amendment to the 1967 Drug Act
that is wending its arduous way through the multi-channeled
Thai legislative system. The men speak in condescending tones, rarely
making eye contact with their small audience of health activists. One
official keeps nodding off.
Tositrakul switches on her microphone and addresses her nominal
counterpart. "We have been working for nearly 20 years to revive the use
of traditional herbal medicine in Thailand," she says, speaking forcefully
and gesticulating for emphasis, "and I don't want all our
efforts to come to nothing."
Point by point, she addresses problems in
the proposed amendment. Soon everyone in the room is sitting up and
leaning forward to listen.
The draft amendment has already been approved by the Cabinet but Dr.
Narong, who has been at his post just over a month, has the authority to
recommend revisions before it moves on from the Council of State to
Parliament and the Senate. Tositrakul called this meeting in November
1999 to see whether
the current secretary general would stick to his predecessors'
promise
to reconsider certain portions of the draft law.
Under the guise of upgrading standards of pharmaceutical
production, the amendment would apply a single criteria Good
Manufacturing Practice to the manufacture of both traditional and
conventional medicines. Tositrakul believes that combining the two
branches of treatment will effectively wipe out traditional medicine
manufacturers
by forcing them to implement expensive production techniques.
Tositrakul cites the experience of Germany, which enacted strict regulations
for the production of herbal medicines. Within 12 years, 85 percent of
small
manufacturers had disappeared. She has been speaking out against the
bill since it was first presented in 1997 and is spearheading lobbying
to make the F.D.A. create a separate, clearly defined manufacturing
practices for traditional medicine.
Traditional Medicine: A Victim of Modernization
Thai consumers will spend an estimated $60 million on imported
medicines in 2000. Tositrakul insists that if the proposed law goes
through and the role of traditional medicine is vastly curtailed, the
Thai public will be forced to rely even more on Western remedies.
"You
should not cut your foot to fit the shoe," is how the 46-year-old
social
activist describes Thailand's approach to regulating its pharmaceutical
industry. "The shoe may be beautiful, but if it hurts your foot you
cannot walk. You should cut the shoe to fit your foot."
After Thailand embarked on modernization in the early 1900s,
hundreds of years' worth of traditional healing practices began falling
into disuse and ultimately disrepute. University-trained physicians told
villagers that their herbal remedies were unscientific and therefore
unsafe.
Government slogans, like "Don't treat yourself, go to the
doctor"
and "If you want medicine, visit the pharmacist," further reinforced
these notions. Although by the late 1970s, only about 30 percent of the
people had access to the care provided by the Ministry of
Public Health, reliance on Western medicine had become synonymous with
"development."
Tositrakul didn't accept the government model. "Around 80 percent of
illnesses are common and can be treated by people themselves," she
maintains. She is a firm believer in humans focusing on creating right
livelihoods for themselves and in being in control of the four basic
necessities: food, clothing, shelter and medicines.
In 1980, as a recent graduate from Thammasat University in Bangkok, Tositrakul teamed up with a friend to form Traditional
Medicine for Self Reliance, an NGO dedicated to reviving the knowledge of
Thai traditional medicine as a means of empowering local communities. In
1990, the name was
changed to Thai Holistic Health Foundation, ThaiHof, to
reflect the expanded scope of the organization's efforts.
"The farmers and village people had the knowledge about herbal
remedies, but at that time they felt inferior and lacked the confidence to trust in their own local
wisdom," she explains in her office at ThaiHof headquarters, a
modest wooden house in a Bangkok suburb. Dressed in a simple patchwork
skirt and blouse made from scraps of traditional Thai silk, she sits
behind a desk half buried under piles of file folders.
|
|
|
Help From the West to Ease Dependence on the West
Tositrakul went from village to village in the Kudchum district, in
the central region of Thailand, collecting data on medicinal plants and
learning
about centuries-old herbal recipes. Initially she disseminated the
information on photocopied pages.
As the document grew from
four to 16 pages, she switched to a magazine format and finally to
publishing small booklets. Today the 40-title library has gone through
more than 10 printings.
Ironically, it was Western intervention that shifted the government's
position on conventional medicine: In 1984 the World Health
Organization began to promote traditional medicine as one element of
primary health care. Around that time, UNICEF funded a project in
Thailand to collect and disseminate data on herbal medicine. As head of
the only NGO working in this field, Tositrakul was invited to join the
committee.
Meanwhile, in Thalaad, a village in Kudchum, she had joined
forces with the abbot of the village temple ("wat" in Thai), a group
of
traditional healers, and a doctor and nurse from the local hospital.
Like Tositrakul, Abbot Phra Supajarawat believed that by alleviating
their poverty and thus their low status, the rural poor's battered
self-esteem would see an upswing. To his mind, environmental ecology was a
tangible route for effecting this change, echoing as it did, the popular
saying: "the forest is a supermarket for the villagers."
The group set up a health center and herb garden in the temple compound in 1983. The
villagers began visiting Wat Thalaad for herbal medicines and, empowered
by their new sense of community, were soon were planting their own
herb gardens. By 1986, Kudchum villagers were spending 75 percent less a
year on conventional medicines, down from approximately 12,000 baht per
family to 3,000 baht.
Learning Lessons in Japan
In 1989 Tositrakul spent a year in Japan working with Masanobu Fukuoka,
a visionary philosopher-cum-agriculturist who believes natural farming
embodies the interrelationship between body and soul. Inspired by
Fukuoka's holistic approach to farming, she translated his seminal book
"The One-Straw Revolution" from English into Thai. The book has been reprinted 10 times in the past 12 years.
In 1990, Tositrakul invited Fukuoka to Thailand to visit farmers in Kudchum and in other parts of the country. She also
organized informational field trips and seminars between farmers in Kudchum
and other provinces. Fukuoka's visit inspired the farmers to follow his
natural farming methods and was the genesis of the pesticide-free rice
farming movement in Thailand.
1990 was a year of change for Tositrakul and ThaiHof.
"When we assessed our progress after the first 10 years, we discovered
our activities were only partly successful," she explains. For example,
despite the reduction in the cost of their medicines, the Kudchum farmers
had
ultimately abandoned growing herbs for their own consumption. They found
the activity too time-consuming and discovered that no other economic
benefits accrued to them save for the reduction in medical bills.
Instead,
they preferred wage employment, which would allow them purchasing power for
ready-made herbs, among other things. To
sustain an activity then, Tositrakul realized her methodology must expand
to include an economic
incentive.
Tositrakul also determined that like the villages it helped, ThaiHof
needed to become self reliant and generate its own income. With no
assistance at first from the government, the NGO was entirely dependent
on
grants from foreign donors.
|
|
|
|
A staunch Buddhist and believer in the nonviolent principles of Mahatma
Gandhi, Tositrakul knew that good health encompasses more than just
physical
wellbeing. "A healthy society doesn't only mean the absence of
disease,"
she says. "It means a more just society. We want to set a good balance
between man, society and nature."
With the rise in health consciousness among Thais brought about by the
concomitant increase in non-communicable diseases cancer, diabetes and
heart disease Tositrakul felt the need for a more holistic approach.
Thus, after a
decade of working solely with farmers and villagers, Tositrakul decided
it
was time to establish links between the rural sector and the
increasingly health conscious urban consumer.
Building the Commercial Underpinnings
These self-assessments led to Friends of Nature, the
income-generating offshoot of ThaiHof. The idea of separating
business activities from social/community development
originated with an outspoken Thai social critic, Prawes Wasi. Making
money
by providing useful products and services was not inherently evil, he
told her, as long as all the profits went to support the social
activity.
Friends of Nature handles all the consumer-related and commercial
aspects of ThaiHof activities. Part retailer, part wholesaler, part
producer, it has grown from a tiny health food store attached to the
ThaiHof offices to a successful and entirely self-sufficient small
company.
Started in 1992 with $80,000 seed money, Friends of Nature
generated nearly $290,000 worth of sales in 1998. Of the 200 items
offered for sale in the store, 40 carry the Friends of Nature brand name (retail sales
accounted for only 30 percent of the total). The $52,000
profit earned in 1998 paid the salaries of its 15 employees and contributed
10 percent toward ThaiHof's $52,000 annual budget.
|
|
|
By the summer of 2000, the country's first traditional health institute should be
up and running on the outskirts of Bangkok. Built with an $84,000 grant
from the Japanese Embassy, it will provide a multidisciplinary approach to holistic
healing.
The early 1990s were also a seminal time for the small farmers of
Kudchum.
For
years rice cultivation had trapped them in a pernicious cycle. To
increase production, they had to rely on expensive fertilizers, which
damaged the soil and kept them indebted to banks and the unscrupulous
mill operators who often cheated them on the weight of their crop.
Fukuoka's visit had introduced them to the concept of non-chemical
farming and reaffirmed the viability of the integrated farming methods
they had abandoned in favor of rice monoculture. Encouraged by a string
of small but crucial successes with the herb gardens and the health
center, the farmers decided to take control over the
mainstay of their livelihood: rice milling.
With about $16,000 as advance payment for milled rice from Friends of
Nature and another $60,000 raised through share offerings, in Sok Khumpoon
village the farmers
formed the "ruk thammachat" group nature care and conservation group
which ran its own rice mill. When the
mill started operations in August 1991, the member-farmers
received an average of $6.70 per metric ton for their pesticide-free
rice
above the market
rate for normally produced rice.
The mill also set up a "rice savings
system," in which farmers keep their rice at the mill and sell it when the
price rises. And instead of
cutting costs by using machines for processing and packaging, the
process of hiring locals was continued. In addition to annual dividends
based on the number of shares held, beginning in 1996 members also
received
a bonus for every ton sold.
Reaching the Critical Mass of Businessgs
Business-savvy friends of ThaiHof taught the farmers accounting and
marketing skills. In an industry renowned for fiduciary fog, the
mill's accounts are a paragon of transparency.
From 302 households in
1992, the farmer-run cooperative grew to nearly 1,100 families in
1999. (A second mill was recently built to cope with the increased
volume of rice.) Now, instead of
looking for work in Bangkok, several university graduates have come
back to their village to manage the business side of the mill.
Tositrakul
is not overly concerned with a temporary financial downturn, due in part
to the devaluation of the Thai currency. As she points out: "Money is not
a measure of success. If you think development is only about money, you
have a very narrow idea."
The Kudchum rice mill was the first in the country to produce brown rice
(initially sold through Friends of Nature but now available at
throughout
Bangkok). From the outset, a few farmers also focused on using fewer
chemicals, motivated partly because of increased consumer awareness,
but
also to reduce their expenses. (In Thailand, the sales-price difference
between organic and conventional rice is small.) Unfortunately the
definitions of chemical-free, pesticide-free and organic are only now
becoming standardized, so early production levels are hard to quantify.
By 1999, 61 Kudchum households were producing 100 percent organic rice
along
with other chemical-free crops. Fifty-five of these same households are
also members of the newly-formed Raw
Materials Center, which produces
organic herbs and sells them to Friends of Nature. The mill was the
first to export organic jasmine rice to Europe.
|
|
Read about the Thai Holistic Health Foundation's strategy to become 100 percent self-financing in the long-term through income generating activities in Changemakers' Creative Resourcing section
|
|
By the end of the next decade Tositrakul hopes to make ThaiHof
completely self-sufficient. Many Thai NGOs depend entirely on the inspiration and
dynamism of a single leader, but she is already training the second
and third generation of self-reliant health activists to ensure
ThaiHof's long-term existence.
"I dream that traditional medicine is a
national product used throughout the country the first priority for
the
common illness," Tositrakul said. "I want to see local industries producing herbal
medicines."
As ThaiHof's philosophy of self reliance through holistic health has
spread, Tositrakul spends more of her time trying to
raise the consciousness of members of the government. In the
process, the humble and self-effacing woman has also raised her public
visibility.
In April 1999, acting as spokeswoman for a network of
30 NGO's, she collected more than 50,000 signatures to demand the
resignation of corrupt Ministry of Public Health officials who had been
implicated in a drug-procurement scandal. The petition, the first of its
kind in Thailand, was mandated by the country's newest constitution.
Surprisingly, the new F.D.A. secretary general agreed about
separating traditional and conventional medicines in the proposed
amendment on quality. He even cited the experience in China, where
patients can choose between the two kinds of treatment. But will he do
anything to
change the bill under consideration?
Tositrakul laughs. "We have
to force him to keep his promise. If you
don't keep sticking to the point, they will forget you. They want to
forget
you." For Rosana Tositrakul, every facet of human existence comprises
holistic health, even politics.
|
|
|
|
Contact:
Thai Holistic Health Foundation
403 Soi 7 Thetsaban Nimit Tai Road
Chatuchak
Bangkok 10900
Tel/Fax (662) 589-4243, 591-8092
Email: thaihof@samart.co.th
Jennifer Gampell is a freelance writer based in Thailand. She writes
about social and cultural topics for international publications including
Time (Asia), the Wall Street Journal and Reader's Digest.
Read more articles on this topic:
|
|
|
February 2000 Journal Home Page
|
|